25 Foreway
Inquire

Free chapter · The House of Davis: A St. Louis Family and the Price of Its Gifts

Chapter 1: The Counter on Market Street

By John W. Davis. About 2,400 words, roughly 10 minutes.

Before there was an international trophy, there was a counter.

It stood on Market Street in St. Louis, in a small store near the old Merchants’ Exchange, a few hundred steps up from the mud of the Mississippi levee. No drawing of it survives. No ledger from its first years has been found. What survives is a sentence in an obituary printed nearly half a century later, which records that a young man from Brookline, Massachusetts, “started in the dry goods trade under the firm name of Standford & Davis,” and that “the store was located then on Market street, near the old Merchants’ Exchange.” A commercial guidebook of the same era adds a second sentence, more revealing than the first: in those days the firm’s “trade, like all other trade of the day, was barter as well as sale.”

The story begins there, with a merchant whose own words have almost entirely disappeared, because everything that followed in the family’s public life rested on what was done at that counter. Goods were measured. Credit was extended or refused. Debts were recorded and, when they went unpaid, pursued — in one surviving instance, by a pair of Springfield lawyers named Lincoln and Herndon. Out of those transactions came a fortune, a building on Washington Avenue that its admirers called “the best dry goods building in the United States,” a family seat on a private street, and three grandsons who were born into more security than their grandfather could have imagined in 1835. One of those grandsons gave his name to the most famous team competition in tennis. Another assembled an important collection of Chinese ceramics, which went to the art museum of his city. Neither story makes sense without the counter.

No diary survives, no memoir, no letter in which Samuel Craft Davis says why he left Massachusetts or what he thought of the city that made him rich. He was born in Brookline, Massachusetts, on January 18, 1809, a son of Robert Sharp Davis and Lucy Stearns, and baptized there on May 7. His father died in August 1821, when the boy was twelve. He survives the way a customer survives in a merchant’s books, as a column of entries.

The St. Louis Globe-Democrat, writing sixty years later, put the family’s situation in the polite language of the Gilded Age: “his parents being in moderate circumstances, he began life without any other advantages than a good education, self reliance, excellent business qualities and a rare energy and perfect integrity.” The sentence tells more about what St. Louis wanted to believe of its founders in 1882 than about the boy in 1821. The obituary presents him as a self-made merchant; no account of his starting capital has been found.

“About 1832,” the obituary continues, “Mr. Davis came West. For a short time he was located at Quincy, Ill., but his keen foresight led him to come here and engage in business.” Quincy was then a raw settlement on the Illinois bank of the Mississippi, a little more than a hundred miles above St. Louis. The newspaper’s “keen foresight” is hindsight. What the record shows is a young man from a farming town outside Boston who tried one river town, then moved to a larger one.

The larger one was not yet large. St. Louis in the early 1830s held perhaps six or seven thousand people, packed along a narrow strip of high ground above the levee. It was still a French town in its street plan and its oldest families, and a frontier depot in its business; the fur trade of the Chouteaus and their partners remained its signature enterprise. Steamboats had been arriving since the Zebulon M. Pike docked in August 1817, and by the 1830s they crowded the landing, because the shallower channel above the city made it the place where cargoes passed between the big lower-river boats and the lighter craft of the upper Mississippi and the Missouri. By 1840 the population stood at 16,469.

In the lithographs J. C. Wild made of the city in 1840 and 1841, the levee is a long slope of stone and mud running down to a wall of steamboat hulls, boats moored bow-in, stacks smoking over hogsheads, barrels, bales and crates, drays turning between them. Goods came up from New Orleans and over the mountains from Philadelphia, Baltimore and New York by way of Pittsburgh and the Ohio; furs, lead, hides and produce went down. A merchant’s place in that traffic was set by the distance between his door and the water. The first Davis store stood close to it.

Two sources locate that store, and they agree in substance. Beside the obituary’s “Market street, near the old Merchants’ Exchange,” the guidebook of 1878, A Tour of St. Louis, puts it “in a little store at Market and Commercial streets, then the business center,” and names his partner as J. R. Stanford. Commercial Street, in the old grid, ran just above the river; Market Street climbed westward from it. The barter trade, the guidebook adds, “was profitable nevertheless, and, what is of more consequence, it grew steadily with the city.”

In 1885, on what it called its semi-centennial, Samuel C. Davis & Co. published a souvenir booklet dating the house to January 19, 1835, and naming three founders: David R. Griggs, J. R. Stanford and Samuel C. Davis. A business that picks its birthday half a century after the fact is choosing a story as well as a date.

What is certain is that by the end of the decade Davis was a partner in not one firm but two. The St. Louis directory compiled for 1840–41 lists “Stanford & Davis, grocers and drygoods merchants, 7 Market,” and, separately, “Davis, Tilden & Richards, dealers in drygoods and groceries, 49 Market.” The first firm was the original partnership; the second joined Davis with John Tilden and Eben Richards, the men the Tour of St. Louis names as his partners after Stanford “retired after a short time.” Both firms dealt in groceries as well as cloth. The house that would later boast of the most specialized dry-goods building in the country began, like most western jobbers, by selling a little of everything.

The name Tilden carries a second thread. On August 13, 1840, at Brookline, Samuel Craft Davis married Caroline Tilden of that town. The marriage recorded something the directories do not: that the young merchant on Market Street remained tied to the Massachusetts village he had left, and that marriage and business tied the family to the East. The couple had two sons: Samuel Jr., the elder, and John Tilden Davis, born in St. Louis on September 13, 1844. The second son’s name joined the two families in a single person, as his own son’s name would later join the Davises to the Filleys.

In May 1837 the banks stopped paying. On May 10 the banks of New York suspended payment in specie; Boston and New Orleans followed on May 12 and 13. One institution conspicuously refused to suspend: the State Bank of Missouri at St. Louis, which kept paying hard money while others did not. The depression that followed lasted, with interruptions, into the early 1840s, and it ended many mercantile careers.

Neither the obituary nor the guidebook mentions the panic. The firm was still in business in 1840, and its senior partner had by then helped found a second house.

The same streets held another kind of commerce. Missouri had entered the Union as a slave state in 1821. Enslaved people lived and worked throughout St. Louis as domestic servants, artisans, deckhands and wharf laborers, and they were bought and sold in the city’s commercial district. Bernard M. Lynch ran a slave market on Locust Street between Fourth and Fifth; his “pens” were former houses with bars across the windows, to which people were brought from the steamboats and from which they were sold. Court-ordered sales of enslaved people, as part of the property of estates and bankrupts, were held on the steps of the courthouse. A National Park Service study of the St. Louis Probate Court records counted 533 individuals who appear in the court documents as offered for sale on the courthouse steps, and 724 named in connection with court-ordered sales; the count excludes every private auction and private sale in the city.

No document examined shows that Samuel Craft Davis owned, hired or sold an enslaved person, and none shows the contrary. The gap stays open. What the record does show is that the economy in which his firm prospered — the river trade, the country stores of Missouri, and, as the house grew, the markets of Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, Louisiana and Texas that the 1878 guidebook would list among its customers — was an economy built in large part on slave labor.

On April 28, 1836, Francis L. McIntosh, a free Black man of about twenty-six from Pittsburgh, a porter and cook on the steamboat Flora, was arrested on the levee after refusing to help two officers seize some sailors. Told he faced years in jail, he stabbed both officers, killing one. A white mob broke into the jail, dragged him to a tree, chained him there and burned him alive. One account puts the tree near what is now Seventh and Chestnut; another, at Tenth and Market. No one was indicted.

Elijah P. Lovejoy, who had condemned the lynching in his St. Louis Observer, was driven across the river to Alton, Illinois, where a crowd shot him dead on November 7, 1837. Two months later a young Springfield lawyer named Abraham Lincoln told the Young Men’s Lyceum that the “horror-striking scene at St. Louis” showed how mob law could destroy a republic: McIntosh, Lincoln said, “was seized in the street, dragged to the suburbs of the city, chained to a tree, and actually burned to death; and all within a single hour from the time he had been a freeman, attending to his own business, and at peace with the world.”

Samuel Craft Davis was in his late twenties and in business on Market Street, a few blocks from the jail, when these things happened. The house of Davis was founded in that city, and grew rich in it.

In 1882 the Globe-Democrat described Davis, after his death, as “a member of the Second Baptist Church and a strict follower of that sect.” It credits him with “perfect integrity” and adds that Davis “gave often, but unostentatiously, shunning all self-glorifying display.”

An obituary’s praise proves little. But the absence of display it describes matches the record’s silence. So far as the records examined show, Davis built no mansion that anyone thought worth describing, endowed no institution that bears his name, and left no portrait that has found its way into a public collection. When the Unitarian minister William Greenleaf Eliot, in the 1850s, sought to make him a director of the new Washington University, he declined. Eliot’s notebook preserves the appeal he sent: the founders hoped to make the school “the leading Univ[ersit]y of the West,” Eliot wrote, and “your position in this community and your … energy of character will greatly aid in its accomplishment.” Eliot added a second reason, more personal — he was “particularly desirous” that Davis’s sons should remain at the university rather than go east, “because it will establish a precedent that others will follow.” The sons did remain; John Tilden Davis graduated from Washington University in 1863. The father did not join the board. The gift the obituary does name went to his own congregation: $10,000 to the building fund of its new church, which, the paper noted, he “never saw.”

By the late 1840s the house of Davis, Tilden & Richards had outlived the Stanford partnership and grown with the city. St. Louis had nearly 45,000 people in the spring of 1849, crowded into a strip about three-quarters of a mile deep along three miles of riverfront; the federal census of the next year counted 77,860. That year it suffered two catastrophes in quick succession.

The first was cholera. Boats from New Orleans brought sick passengers and dead ones in January; by spring the disease was established, and by the end of the year it had killed at least 4,317 people by one modern count, and probably more. A contemporary journal counted 4,285 cholera deaths among 8,445 from all causes. The city’s death register did not begin until 1850, and many victims were buried beyond the city limits.

The second came on the night of May 17. The steamboat White Cloud, moored at the foot of Cherry Street, was burning. According to a Post-Dispatch history of the fire, crewmen had put out a mattress fire, aired the bedding on deck and dragged it back into a cabin, missing an ember. The alarm sounded at about nine (ten, by one account). The volunteer firemen came with nine hand engines and hose reels, but the flames spread to a neighboring boat, the Bates, which burned free of its mooring and drifted down the crowded landing. Twenty-three boats burned, and some fifteen blocks of the business district east of Third Street.

The Tour of St. Louis gives the outcome for the house in one sentence: “The great fire of 1849, the most sweeping conflagration that has ever visited St. Louis, just stopped short of their house in its destructive course.” The house was spared. Its neighbors were not.

The burned district was rebuilt in brick and iron, four and five stories high. For a merchant whose stock survived, a competitor’s burned inventory was no misfortune. The Tour goes on to note that “changes in the firm from time to time occasionally occurred, but the controlling interest always remained with Mr. Davis, and his active and sagacious mind directed the operations of the business.” Within a few years the house would carry his name alone.

The 1878 guidebook that kept the sentence about the fire also described the firm’s later building on Washington Avenue, and one of its details is hard for a historian to read. The basement of the new building, the Tour reports, was “provided with fire-proof vaults, in which the old books and accounts of the firm are preserved.”

The old books and accounts: the record of every bolt sold on credit to a country storekeeper upriver, of every note taken and every debt written off in 1837, of the stock that survived the fire of 1849. In 1878 they sat in a fireproof vault on Washington Avenue. They have not been found.